Your Property Tax
Cincinnati property owners will pay the same tax rate next year as now, but that means the city must fill an even bigger deficit for 2012; $33 million.
. The decision Wednesday by City Council to hold the rate steady means the city will take in $24 million in property tax revenue next year – down from the almost $29 million taken annually for a decade. A new county-wide reassessment meant Cincinnati saw its property values drop 7 percent.
. They say they’re holding the only line they can on uncontrolled spending at City Hall. One of the five, Leslie Ghiz said the initial responsibility for balancing the budget lay with the city manager, not council. “It’s not our job to figure out how to close that (budget) gap,” she said. (“It’s the manager’s job to figure out how to close the budget [gap]“).
. The Democrats called it irresponsible to choose to bring in less money to a city already facing a deficit–especially without producing definitive, workable cuts to cover the lost money.
. How much a homeowner might save depends on whether his or her property value went up or down. About 70 percent of properties in the city declined. If the value of a $100,000 house stayed the same after re-evaluation, that owner would pay no more than the current $300. If the value of that same home is down 7 percent, city officials said that $300 tax bill would go down $10.
. The tax amount had to be settled Wednesday to meet a July 20 deadline for having the amount to the Hamilton County auditor.
Source: Council keeps taxes steady, raising deficit. By Jane Prendergast, The Enquirer 6/30/11 A1
6/18/11 A lawyer said, across Hamilton County, there is (about) a 7% reduced property value. Even if your assessed value stays the same, you will get (about) a 6 percent dollar tax increase, without a vote of the people. It will automatically go up. It will be included in your next tax bill.
Note: this message was sent to Sycamore board members, selected media and interested residents June 18, 2011.
===================================================
Have you looked at your tax bill lately? Read on and see how much you are paying. Ever wonder where your property tax money is going? Did you know that 57%-63% of your residential tax bill is going to the school district?
How many tax dollars do you currently pay for the schools? Based on an extrapolation of a recent half year tax bill, the full year school tax bill for a $300,000 Blue Ash home could be about $2,800.
DEFEATING THE LEVY WILL REDUCE YOUR TAXES.
| 2009 Estimated Blue Ash Residential Property Tax | |||
| $300,000 Market Value | |||
| Half Year* | Full Year | % of total*** | |
| approx.** | |||
| School District-Sycamore | $1400.54 | $2801.08 | 63% |
| City/Village-Blue Ash | $141.50 | $283.00 | 6% |
| Mental Retardation Levy | $138.24 | $276.48 | 6% |
| County General Fund | $103.83 | $207.66 | 5% |
| Joint Vocational School | $91.88 | $183.76 | 4% |
| Children Services | $75.64 | $151.28 | 3% |
| Hlth/Hospital Care-Indigent | $73.00 | $146.00 | 3% |
| Mental Health Levy | $67.54 | $135.08 | 3% |
| Senior Services | $40.82 | $81.44 | 2% |
| Park District | $35.73 | $71.46 | 2% |
| Hlth/Hospital Care-Drake | $32.08 | $64.16 | 1% |
| Zoological Park | $14.54 | $29.08 | 1% |
| Museum Center | $7.64 | $15.28 | 0% |
| Crime Information Center | $6.70 | $13.40 | 0% |
| County Voted Bond Debt | $6.43 | $12.86 | 0% |
| Total | $2236.11 | $4472.22 | 99% |
| * Half Year estimate. Source: Hamiltoncountyauditor.org | |||
| Estimate performed on 1/5/2009 with tax dist=214, | |||
| market value estimate=300,000 and land use=Residential | |||
| Tax District Blue Ash-Sycamore-00060 | |||
| ** Full Year approximate calculation (2 x Half Year actual dollar amount will be different). | |||
| *** Doesn’t equal 100% because of rounding | |||
Now see what YOU are paying.
Click http://www.hamiltoncountyauditor.org/realestate/rover30.asp
enter your own address and see what you are paying by clicking on “Taxes Paid.”
———————————————————————————–
The following chart shows comparative school tax rates for some local districts. Note: Assuming all of the eventual $12 million loss TPP revenue is shifted to property owners, Sycamore’s equivalent 30.4 effective millage rate would increase 23 % to about 37.4 effective mills. ………………………………………………………..
http://www.hamiltoncountyauditor.org/pdf/re_100k2009_byschools.pdf
| RANKING ORDER FROM HIGHEST TO LOWEST COST | |||||
| TAX YEAR 2008-COLLECTION YEAR 2009 | |||||
| ANNUAL COST | |||||
| School | RESIDENTIAL | ||||
| Total Res/Ag | $100K MARKET | ||||
| Effective | 10% / 2.5% | ||||
| SCHOOL DISTRICT | Rate | STC | |||
| MADEIRA | 44.868615 | $1,331.89 | |||
| FINNEYTOWN | 44.703565 | $1,326.99 | |||
| ST.BERNARD | 43.273321 | $1,284.53 | |||
| CINCINNATI* | 42.704083 | $1,267.64 | |||
| MT. HEALTHY | 41.587971 | $1,234.51 | |||
| MARIEMONT | 40.819280 | $1,211.69 | |||
| LOVELAND | 39.259492 | $1,165.39 | |||
| MILFORD | 39.126008 | $1,161.42 | |||
| WYOMIMG | 37.764939 | $1,121.02 | |||
| WINTON WOODS | 37.714260 | $1,119.52 | |||
| LOCKLAND | 37.059609 | $1,100.09 | |||
| DEER PARK | 36.273464 | $1,076.75 | |||
| N COLEGE HILL | 32.738809 | $971.83 | |||
| FOREST HILLS | 31.875216 | $946.19 | |||
| SYCAMORE^ | 30.486116 | $904.96 | |||
| READING | 28.749881 | $853.42 | |||
| NORWOOD | 28.699999 | $851.94 | |||
| NORTHWEST** | 28.158609 | $835.87 | |||
| OAK HILLS | 27.525871 | $817.08 | |||
| THREE RIVERS | 27.064080 | $803.38 | |||
| INDIAN HILL | 23.579326 | $699.93 | |||
| PRINCETON | 23.534425 | $698.60 | |||
| SOUTHEAST | 23.460010 | $696.39 | |||
| GREAT OAKS JVSD | 2.000000 | $59.37 | |||
| BUTLER TECH JVSD | 1.930000 | $57.29 | |||
| * Cincinnati CSD does not participate in the Great Oaks JVSD | |||||
| ** Northwest LSD participates in the Butler Tech. JVSD | |||||
| Note: This information was copied by hand from the Hamilton County Auditor | |||||
| Budget Settlement Dept. web site on 1/12/2009. Any errors are accidential. | |||||
————————————————————————————————–.
This chart shows the rates of taxation. They are different than the school effective tax rate shown in the prior chart.
| Rates of Taxation for Taxes Paid in 2009 (for Sycamore School Tax District only) | ||||||||||||||
| TOWN- | JOINT | TOTAL | ||||||||||||
| TAX | TOWNSHIP | SCHOOL | SCHOOL | COUNTY | SHIP | SCHOOL | CORP. | VOC. | FULL | REDUCTION FACTORS | EFFECTIVE RATES | PRIOR | ||
| DISTRICT | DISTRICT | LEVY | LEVY | LEVY | LEVY | LEVY | RATE | RESID./ | COMM./ | RESID./ | COMM./ | YEAR | ||
| NUMBER | # | MILLS | MILLS | MILLS | MILLS | MILLS | MILLS | AGRL. | IND. | AGRL. | IND. | RATE | ||
| 214 | Blue Ash | Sycamore | 21 | 20.63 | 65.77 | 3.08 | 2.70 | 92.18 | 0.471972 | 0.353529 | 48.67362 | 59.5917 | 92.13 | |
| 216 | Evendale | Sycamore | 21 | 20.63 | 65.77 | 2.70 | 89.10 | 0.488287 | 0.365750 | 45.59362 | 56.5117 | 89.05 | ||
| 218 | Indian Hill | Sycamore | 21 | 20.63 | 65.77 | 0.96 | 2.70 | 90.06 | 0.483082 | 0.361851 | 46.55362 | 57.4717 | 90.01 | |
| 217 | Loveland | Sycamore | 21 | 20.63 | 65.77 | 10.28 | 2.70 | 99.38 | 0.443865 | 0.335480 | 55.26869 | 66.04 | 99.33 | |
| 211 | Montgomery | Sycamore | 21 | 20.63 | 65.77 | 10.05 | 2.70 | 99.15 | 0.459848 | 0.342642 | 53.55606 | 65.1771 | 99.10 | |
| 215 | Sharonville | Sycamore | 21 | 20.63 | 65.77 | 2.70 | 89.10 | 0.488287 | 0.365750 | 45.59362 | 56.5117 | 89.05 | ||
| 210 | Sycamore | Sycamore | 21 | 20.63 | 8.75 | 65.77 | 2.70 | 97.85 | 0.461823 | 0.345917 | 52.66059 | 64.002 | 97.80 | |
| 212 | Symmes | Sycamore | 21 | 20.63 | 13.70 | 65.77 | 2.70 | 102.80 | 0.472025 | 0.360784 | 54.27586 | 65.7114 | 102.75 | |
| Rates of Taxation on one ($1.00) dollar in the Sycamore School District of Hamilton County for the tax year 2008, with comparative rates for | ||||||||||||||
| the tax year 2007, as prepared by Hamilton County Auditor Dusty Rhodes. | ||||||||||||||
| Note: This information was copied by hand from the Hamilton County Auditor Budget Settlement Dept. web site on 1/8/2009. Any errors | ||||||||||||||
| are accidential. | ||||||||||||||
| ANNUAL COST BY HAMILTON COUNTY LEVIES FOR A $100,00 MARKET VALUE HOME | ||||||||
| Homeowner is receiving the 10% rollback, 2.5% reduction and current sales tax credit. | ||||||||
| TAX YEAR 2008-COLLECTION YEAR 2009 | ||||||||
| ANNUAL COST | ||||||||
| County Levy | RESIDENTIAL | |||||||
| Total Res/Ag | $100K MARKET | |||||||
| Effective | 10% / 2.5% | |||||||
| COUNTY LEVY | Rate | STC | ||||||
| GENERAL FUND | 2.260000 | 67.09 | ||||||
| HEALTH / HOSPITAL – UNIVERSITY | 1.588918 | 47.17 | ||||||
| HEALTH / HOSPITAL – DRAKE | 0.698205 | 20.73 | ||||||
| COUNTY PARK DISTRICT | 0.777648 | 23.08 | ||||||
| COUNTY POLICE INFORMATION CENTER | 0.145790 | 4.33 | ||||||
| CARE & TRAINING OF THE MENTALLY RETARDED | 3.008933 | 89.32 | ||||||
| COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH | 1.470206 | 43.64 | ||||||
| SUPPORT OF CHILDREN’S SERVICE | 1.646501 | 48.88 | ||||||
| BOND RETIREMENT & INTEREST | 0.140000 | 4.16 | ||||||
| SUPPORT OF SENIOR SERVICES | 0.888633 | 26.38 | ||||||
| ZOOOLOGICAL PURPOSES | 0.316427 | 9.39 | ||||||
| MUSEUM CENTER | 0.166239 | 4.93 | ||||||
| TOTAL RATE | 13.107500 | 389.09 | ||||||
| Source: Budget Settlement Dept. Hamilton County Auditor TY2008 Web Updates ACSIS.XLS 1/8/2009 | ||||||||
http://www.hamiltoncountyauditor.org/pdf/re_100k2009_bylevies.pdf
Property owners in the Cincinnati Public School district will have to pay slightly more next year in property taxes because of a technicality in the way school levies work.
..Because of declines in property values, two emergency levies for the district of nearly 33,00 students are collecting $1.9 million less than anticipated. The district is required to increase the levy millage to keep pace with the dollar amount that voters agreed to give to the schools when they passed those levies. The district is increasing the millage of the two levies by a total of .35 mills – from 19.06 mills to 19.41 mills. The change will cost the owner of a home valued at $100,000 and additional $12 in property taxes annually. CPS increases the millage of a levy last year due to low property value estimates. In 2008 it decreased levy millage because property values had gone up.
..Source: Shortfall forces CPS to increase property tax THE ENQUIRER 12/8/11 C3
Appraisers go by recent comparable sales six months back to establish a value for a house, and Realtors go back six to 12 months to do the same thing, she (Jessica Bauer) said.
.
It’s a good thing to have a low value because you’re paying lower taxes while you own the property,” said Christopher Finney, a leader of the anti-tax group Coalition Opposed to Additional Spending and Taxes.
.
For taxpayers: The lower assessed values may mean higher tax rates – though not necessarily higher tax bills. When voters pass levies for school or police or roads, those levies are for set dollar amounts. As assessed values fall, each property will have to chip in a higher percentage of the home’s value to ensure the levy brings in what it’s supposed to.
.
Those with properties whose value declined less than neighbors’ will end up paying more taxes; those whose properties declined more than their neighbors’ will pay less.
Source: County values your say. By Sharon Coolidge. The Enquirer , 6/4/11 A1
Hamilton County property owners are $5 billion poorer than they were last year.
.
A once-every-six-years reassessment found that the county’s property is now valued at $57.6 billion – an almost 8 percent drop from what properties had been assessed last year.
.
The declines – which Rhodes said are unprecedented – will have huge repercussions for taxpayers, governments, and real estate buyers and sellers:
• For taxpayers, the lower assessed values may mean higher tax rates – though not necessarily higher tax bills. When voters pass levies for schools or police or roads, those levies are for set dollar amounts. As assessed values fall, each property, on average, will have to chip in a higher percent of the home’s value to ensure the levy brings in what it’s supposed to.
.
Those with properties whose value declined less than their neighbors’ will end up paying more taxes: those whose properties declined more than their neighbors’ will pay less.
.
When schools or villages ask for levies on a ballot, the rates sought for those levies may seem higher than in the past, and could make them less likely to pass.
• A decreased assessment could lead to a lower sale price.
One factor in the property value decline: an onslaught of foreclosures or sales of distressed property at rock-bottom prices.
.
Final values will be set this fall. Residents won’t know the effect of the reappraisals on their taxes until they get their first 2012 tax bill.
.
Property value by municipality
Blue Ash: 14.86% change 2010-2011
Montgomery: -7.46% change 2010-2011
Indian Hill: -12% change 2010-2011
.
Source: Hamilton County property lost $5 billion in value Housing crash took toll in foreclosures and desperation sales. By Sharon Coolidge and Lisa Bernard-Kuhn THE ENQUIRER 4/21/11 A1
Ohio Local Law Tax Basics
http://www.beavercreektax.net/tax_laws.html =
This letter appeared in the Jan. 26, 2009 Enquirer.
Home values set to market
In regard to the letter “Property audit outrageous” (Jan. 16), the county auditor’s office is required by state law to set values to current market. We set values. Residents of each community set their taxes by voting for tax levies. Our new values are being compared by some to recent, short-term market activity when they are actually changes from the previous value set as of Jan. 1, 2005. We have no legal authority to extend “sympathy,” if that means arbitrarily lowering a value, to any property owner for any reason. We have to follow the law.
—Dusty Rhodes
Hamilton County auditor